
How to Check Vintage Clothing Fastenings Before You Buy

Fastenings are easy to overlook when shopping for vintage clothing online, yet they have a direct effect on comfort, function and future care. A beautiful coat with a reluctant zip or a dress with strained buttonholes may still be worth considering, but the details should be understood before you buy.
This practical guide explains how to assess buttons, zips, hooks, press studs and buckles from photographs and descriptions, without assuming that every older fastening must be perfect. The aim is to make a better-informed choice and to recognise when a simple repair may be enough.

Why fastenings deserve a closer look
A fastening takes repeated pressure every time a garment is worn. Its condition can therefore reveal more than appearance alone: loose stitching may show regular use, distorted buttonholes can suggest strain, and puckering beside a zip may indicate that the surrounding fabric needs attention.
None of these signs automatically makes a garment unsuitable. Many buttons can be resewn and some hooks can be replaced neatly. The useful question is whether the fastening works with the garment, whether the nearby fabric remains sound, and whether any repair feels proportionate to the piece.
How to inspect vintage buttons
Count, compare and check placement
Start by counting the buttons shown in the listing photographs. Compare their colour, shape, size and spacing. A replacement button is not necessarily a problem, especially on an older garment, but a noticeably different one should be described or clearly visible so you can decide whether the variation suits you.
Look for a spare button inside a pocket or attached near a care label, while remembering that not every garment was supplied with one. On double-breasted coats and fitted jackets, check that the rows appear balanced and that the fabric is not pulling sharply between closures.
Look closely at stitching and buttonholes
Button thread should sit securely without cutting deeply into fragile fabric. A small amount of movement may be intentional where a shank gives thicker cloth room to close. What matters is whether the button is attached firmly enough for use and whether the surrounding cloth shows tears or enlarged holes.
Buttonholes should look stable at their edges. Light wear can be manageable, but fraying that extends into the main fabric may need careful reinforcement. If the photographs do not show the buttonholes clearly, it is reasonable to ask for a close-up.
How to assess a vintage zip
Check teeth, slider and surrounding fabric
A listing may say that a zip works, but photographs can still provide useful clues. Look for missing or misaligned teeth, a slider sitting at an angle, a damaged pull tab, or fabric caught repeatedly near the track. On metal zips, a little surface wear can be part of the garment's age; it should not be confused with missing components.
The fabric beside the zip deserves equal attention. Rippling may simply reflect how the garment is lying, while torn tape, loose stitching or a split seam can affect how reliably the fastening works. On trousers and skirts, inspect the base of the zip where stress often concentrates.
Ask for a practical confirmation
If the listing is unclear, ask whether the zip opens and closes fully, whether it separates when gently tensioned, and whether the pull moves without force. A short, factual answer is more useful than a vague description. Avoid expecting a seller to guarantee future performance; the goal is to understand its present condition.
Hooks, press studs and buckles
Hooks and eyes should meet cleanly without dragging the garment out of line. Check that both parts are present and that the stitching around them is secure. Concealed hooks at a waistband or neckline can be small, so a close photograph is often the best way to confirm condition.
Press studs should have both halves and sit flat. Rust, cracking, distortion or fabric pulling away from the stud may call for repair. Buckles should retain their pin or slider, and covered buckles should be checked for worn fabric at the edges. For belts, compare the buckle width with the strap so the fastening does not look mismatched.
Questions to ask when buying online
Do all buttons, hooks, press studs and buckle parts appear to be present?
Does the zip travel fully in both directions without separating or catching?
Are any fastenings replacements, and are spare matching parts included?
Is there fraying, tearing or stretching in the fabric around the closure?
Can the seller provide one clear close-up of any area that is not visible?
Keep questions focused on information that cannot be seen. Clear requests are easier to answer and help avoid assumptions about materials, age or originality.
When a repair may be worthwhile
Simple maintenance
Resewing a loose button, replacing a basic hook or reinforcing sound stitching can be straightforward for someone with suitable skills. Save any original components in a labelled envelope, especially if a button or buckle may be useful for a later repair.
Repairs that need more judgement
A zip replacement, torn button placket or damaged covered buckle may involve more labour and can change the appearance of the garment. Delicate, lined or structured pieces may benefit from assessment by an experienced repairer. Consider the fabric condition as a whole before committing to work.
Make fastenings part of your buying routine
Checking closures takes only a few moments and can make online vintage shopping more predictable. Look at the hardware, the stitching and the surrounding fabric together; note what is visible, ask for what is missing, and decide whether any repair suits your budget and intended use.
Explore RMAR Vintage shop collections for pre-owned style, or visit the RMAR eBay shop to browse the current selection. Availability changes, so use each listing's photographs and description as the source for item-specific details.



Comments